If I Were to Choose a Religion: An Objective Evaluation
Keywords: choosing a religion, why Islam, Islam vs other religions, truth in religion, objective view on religion, divine message, unaltered scriptures, search for truth
Introduction: The Importance of a Fair Search
Choosing a religion is one of the most profound decisions a human being can make. It demands intellectual honesty, emotional sincerity, and a deep willingness to find the ultimate truth. If I were to approach the question of religion without prior bias—examining evidence, history, theology, and human nature objectively—certain key criteria would guide my search:
- A clear, consistent, and rational understanding of God
- Authenticity and preservation of divine revelation
- Coherence between faith, reason, and human nature
- Practical systems for individual well-being and societal harmony
- Historical credibility and impact
Applying these standards evenly across all major religious traditions, I would conclude that
Islam offers the most comprehensive, preserved, and rational approach to divine truth.
1. Clarity of Belief in God (Tawheed)
The Islamic concept of God (Allah) is remarkably pure and logical. Islam asserts
absolute monotheism (Tawheed): there is one, unique, eternal, and all-powerful Creator without partners, sons, or intermediaries. This understanding avoids theological complexities like the Trinity, incarnations, or polytheism.
The Qur'an describes Allah:
"Say, He is Allah, the One and Only; Allah, the Eternal, Absolute; He begets not, nor is He begotten; and there is none comparable unto Him." (Qur'an, 112:1-4)
This definition aligns perfectly with innate human reasoning about a singular, perfect Creator.
2. Preservation of the Divine Message
Islam holds that the Qur'an is the final and unaltered revelation from God. Unlike previous scriptures, which many scholars admit have undergone changes, the Qur'an has been meticulously preserved in its original Arabic for over 1400 years, both through written manuscripts and memorization by millions of people (Hafiz system).
Historical evidence and even non-Muslim researchers agree on the Qur'an’s textual stability, making it a unique living miracle.
3. Compatibility with Human Nature
Islam’s teachings are deeply in tune with human instincts and needs. Its rituals, such as prayer (salah), fasting (sawm), charity (zakat), and pilgrimage (hajj), serve to discipline the soul while nurturing compassion, gratitude, and social responsibility.
Furthermore, Islamic ethics—promoting justice, mercy, honesty, patience, and humility—resonate universally across cultures and times. The moral code Islam advocates is natural, comprehensive, and not burdensome.
4. Historical Reality and Impact
The life of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the most well-documented in history. His honesty, patience, forgiveness, and leadership are recognized not just by Muslim sources but by secular historians as well.
Under his guidance, Islam transformed desert tribes into a civilization that would contribute to humanity’s progress in fields like medicine, mathematics, astronomy, and philosophy. Such impact indicates divine support for his mission.
5. Balance Between Reason and Faith
Islam encourages the use of reason alongside faith. The Qur'an frequently invites reflection:
"Do they not reflect upon themselves? Allah created the heavens and the earth and everything between them in truth and for an appointed term." (Qur'an, 30:8)
Islam does not ask believers to accept blind dogmas; instead, it calls for thinking, questioning, and understanding.
Conclusion: Why Islam Stands Out
Evaluating religion based on fairness, reason, history, and human nature,
Islam emerges as the strongest choice. It offers:
- A pure, rational understanding of God
- A historically preserved revelation
- A harmonious balance between faith, intellect, and society
- Practical guidance for both spiritual and worldly success
Thus, if I were a human seeking truth with an unbiased heart and mind,
I would choose Islam without hesitation.
Islam is not simply a belief system; it is a comprehensive way of life that satisfies both the heart and the mind, illuminating the path toward eternal success.
Akılları olsaydı zaten kabul ederlerdi ama bazıları gerçekten ahiretini mahvetme derdinde. İnsan ömrü ortalama 70 yıl, bu 70 yılda islamı inkar ederek sonsuz bir zaman diliminden vazgeçiyorlar . Gerçekten hem acınacak, hemde üzülünecek haldeler. 70 sene için ahiretten vazgeçen insanların beyin yapılarını gerçekten merak ediyorum. Nasıl bir düşünceye sahipler ki, böyle bir bedbahtsızlık içindeler.
